Due to the fact that Guess Seductive vs Guess Seductive Noir are completely different in terms of scent profiles, choosing between the two will depend on your personal taste.
In the world of fragrances, some fragrances in the same canon have similar scent profiles and the only distinguishing factor in these cases is the concentration of each classification of the fragrances.
On the other hand, there are fragrances that are a part of the same canon, but that have disparate scent profiles.
In one of Guess’ most popular fragrance canons, the Seductive range of fragrances, one of the most popular fragrances from the canon is the Guess Seductive Noir.
This fragrance is compared to Guess Seductive, which is arguably an unfair comparison as the two fragrances are different in classification, note details, and the perfumer behind the nose designs.
Guess Seductive: A brief history
Guess launched its Seductive fragrance canon with Guess Seductive, which was first launched in 2010. The first release was a fragrance for women.
In 2011, Guess expanded its Seductive canon with the release of Guess Seductive Homme, which is an amber woody fragrance for men. Guess Seductive I’m Yours was released in the same year.
The brand had seemingly struck gold with the release of the Homme for men. As a result, it introduced Guess Seductive Blue Homme for men in 2012.
The fragrance borrowed note details from its predecessor, as it was also classified as a woody aquatic fragrance for men.
Guess Seductive vs Guess Seductive Noir
Guess Seductive Noir was released in 2019, nine years after the release of the first fragrance in the Guess Seductive range.
Moreover, the release of the Seductive Noir for women marked a return to creating fragrances for women in the Seductive canon as the 2011 Guess Seductive I’m Yours fragrance did not garner the same appreciation and popularity as the Guess Seductive Homme, released in the same year.
So, when Guess Seductive Noir was released and it garnered the popularity it deserves, comparisons were being made between the Guess Seductive Noir and the Guess Seductive.
Although this is a somewhat unfair comparison, as the two fragrances cannot be compared in any of the aspects that matter.
A detailed side-by-side look of the fragrances shows the following:
| Perfume | Guess Seductive | Guess Seductive Noir |
| Nose design | Veronique Nyberg | Laurent Le Guernec |
| Classification | Floral fruity fragrance for women | Amber floral fragrance for women |
| Top notes | Pear, bergamot and black currant | Sage, bergamot, and peony |
| Middle notes | Jasmine, African orange flower, and orris root | Iris, jasmine sambac, and Lily-of-the-Valley |
| Base notes | Vanille, cashmere wood, and olibanum | Vanilla, velvet, and Haitian vetiver |
| Price | From $22.58 for a 75ml bottle on Amazon | From $20.88 for a 75ml bottle on Amazon |
| Where to buy |
Guess Seductive vs Guess Seductive Noir: Which one to buy
Considering that Guess Seductive and Guess Seductive Noir are completely different fragrances released in the same canon, deciding on which one to purchase should be determined by which fragrance is popular in the market.
If that is the case, Guess Seductive Noir would be a better purchase. Firstly, the decision can be attributed to the more affordable price tag between the two.
Secondly, the decision can be made based on which fragrance is more unique, and unanimously, the public believes that the Noir has the better fragrance profile between the two. Therefore, overall, the better purchase is the Guess Seductive Noir.
Guess Seductive Noir vs Mon Guerlain
A viable comparison with the Guess Seductive Noir is the 2017 fragrance by Guerlain, Mon Guerlain.
Angelina Jolie was the fragrance’s ambassador, and it is believed that when Guess designed Noir, it was inspired in part by Mon Guerlain, as they share similar note profiles.
A side-by-side look of the two reveals:
| Perfume | Mon Guerlain | Guess Seductive Noir |
| Nose design | Thierry Wasser and Delphine Jelk | Laurent Le Guernec |
| Classification | Amber floral fragrance for women | Amber floral fragrance for women |
| Top notes | Lavender and bergamot | Sage, bergamot, and peony |
| Middle notes | Iris, jasmine sambac, and rose | Iris, jasmine sambac, and Lily-of-the-Valley |
| Base notes | Tahitian vanilla, coumarin, Australian sandalwood, liquorice, benzoin, and patchouli | Vanilla, velvet, and Haitian vetiver |
| Price | From $40.27 for a 30ml bottle on Amazon | From $20.88 for a 75ml bottle on Amazon |
| Where to buy |
Guess Seductive’s biggest criticism
If you are wondering whether it is advisable to purchase the Guess Seductive fragrance, the simple answer is no.
The fragrance has not been well-reviewed as a stand-alone fragrance. Its biggest criticism is that it is not complex or unique in any way, but generic at best.
Moreover, if you are looking for a floral fruity fragrance, there are other fragrances that are better in terms of fragrance profiles, sillage, and longevity. The Guess Seductive has a sillage that is moderate, lasting just over six hours.